On this day sixty-five years ago, American forces broke out of the Anzio beachhead and began the long process of pushing the Germans out of Italy. In American military history, the invasion is known as a poorly executed near disaster. In my family’s history, it is remembered as the moment when my father came to terms with the role of chance in an individual’s life.
At Anzio, Allied war planners hoped to outflank the Germans by landing fifty miles behind the Nazi lines. Although the initial landing on January 22 went well, the general in charge was too cautious and did not press his advantage. The Nazis under Field Marshall Kesselring regrouped and counterattacked, pinning the soldiers down at the beachhead. It took the Allies some four months and 43,000 casualties to advance.
My father was one of the millions of American men who were plucked from farms, cities, and classrooms to land on the beaches of Normandy, Okinawa, and Anzio. Before the war, he had never been further than 50 miles from his small town in Michigan. The first member of his family to attend college, he was thrilled when he was accepted to Central Michigan University. But then the war, and the draft notice, came. He enlisted in the Navy to avoid the Army.
After 90 days in midshipman’s school in Chicago, he found himself on a Liberty Ship heading to North Africa. Within two weeks, he was the skipper on a Landing Craft Tank, a small flat-bottomed craft with a dozen crew members and the unenviable task of landing men and machines on the beach during amphibious invasions. He had never even seen an LCT before, but the Navy placed him in charge of one the day before an invasion.
On their second run toward the shore, catastrophe struck. The chain holding the LCT’s anchor snapped off, and the ship, tossed by waves, smashed to shore. The crew members hesitantly emerged to find themselves on the deck of a disabled craft, onlookers to history.
There wasn’t much to see at the beginning. The infantry came; tens of thousands of Americans massed on the beach, then headed into the hills. But then the Nazis counterattacked. Most of the fighting took place a few miles inland, but the men on the beach still took cover from occasional bombs dropped by the Luftwaffe and artillery shells lobbed from the nearby hills. My father’s ship and crew never took a direct hit, probably because the Germans didn’t want to waste their ammunition on them. Mostly, they sat on the deck, watching the soldiers stream by and begging water and rations from them. The days dragged on, because the Navy could not spare the time to pull them off the rocks. Both sides regarded the handful of men on the beached boat as unimportant, which, in a war, is not entirely a bad thing.
I was born when he was already well into middle age, so his memories were distant by the time I began to pester him about them. He always emphasized the surreal aspects: how he had never wanted to go, yet had served nearly four years; how he didn’t know how to swim, yet had captained a ship around the world. Mostly, though, I remember how stunned he was by his own survival, when so many around him had died. If not for the accident in Anzio, which put his ship out of commission for five months, he might have been sent to Normandy.
When I was backpacking around Europe in the late 1980s, I took a detour to Anzio from Rome and snapped some pictures. Later, when I showed the photos to my dad, he stared hard at the Italian families playing on the beach where, four and a half decades earlier, he had seen men die. “Golly,” he finally managed to say. Then he got up and left the room.
Anzio was just the beginning for my father. He helped invade southern France, against little opposition; he delivered supplies across the Pacific. After the war, still denied the privilege of going home, he helped command a bigger amphibious ship, an LSM, up and down the Yellow River in China. The scrapbook of this Michigan farmboy contains photos of Roman monuments, Moroccan beggars, and crowded Asian markets.
He came home to the GI Bill and VA loans. He had grown up in a one-room house without running water or electricity, but after the war a grateful government sent him to graduate school and helped him buy a piece of the American Dream in a Southern California suburb. The war was the most terrifying event of his life, but it opened up a world of possibilities.
11 comments
May 24, 2009 at 1:39 pm
stevenattewell
Regarding chance in war, I absolutely agree. My grandfather, for example, was in the Royal Engineers sent over to France in 1940 to build train roundhouses that were supposed to improve transportation of supplies to the front that was supposed to be established outside of France. Since he spoke French, he was chosen to be radio operator, and heard the reports coming in when the blitzkrieg broke through Allied lines, and told his commander, who suggested that it might be the thing to get out of the way. They didn’t make it to Dunkirk, instead they ended up heading west to Saint-Nazaire, where they were put on board the RMS Lancastria.
Because the converted passenger liner was about twice capacity, they locked the passengers belowdecks to keep them from interfering with the sailors. Then the ship got hit by Junkers about nine miles out of harbor. My grandfather managed to climb up from the hold, only to find the doors chained shut, then had to go back down and find another stairs. He got out just as the ship sank, and had to swim under burning oil to safety as the Junkers strafed the wreckage with tracer rounds. He was one of 2,477 survivors, out of a total complement of anywhere from 4-9,000.
When he got back to the U.K and recovered, he was sent out to Singapore and got there just before Singapore fell to the Japanese. He managed to get the hell out, and made his way to Bombay, where he ended up with the Bombay Sappers, building railroads and bridges and then blowing them up again as the lines shifted back and forth. The stories he told about rattling around corduroy roads with massive crates of “weepy” gelignite terrified me.
Yet he survived, he got lucky.
May 24, 2009 at 2:26 pm
saintneko
The Anzio beachhead was mentioned in Pink Floyd’s The Wall (cinematic version only, not the album) though there is some disagreement as to whether or not it’s beachhead or bridgehead in the lyrics (at least according to a quick google search for lyrics) – I don’t happen to have the DVD handy at this moment so I can’t fact-check that myself.
May 24, 2009 at 4:21 pm
Charlieford
My father joined the Navy right away, December 8th. But he was happy to admit it wasn’t only or even mostly patriotism. He knew that in the Navy he’d get to shower every day, and there’d be warm meals, two things that were very important to him. Life in the Army would have been too dirty and ill-fed.
May 24, 2009 at 5:23 pm
herbert browne
My dad flew B-17s out of southern Italy, winter of ’44-’45, from a British base, at first. He never spoke of the war until 30 years later, when he stopped by to visit me on the Oregon Coast… and a friend of mine who was there asked him some questions. My friend was a “WWII buff” of the European war, and knew enough to ask “what bomber Group when dad said “15th Air Force”. So I heard things about the war that day which were a sort of ‘wedge’ into his reticence on the subject.
He said that, while training in ’44 in the States that he was “afraid it’d be over before he had his chance.” By the war’s end his attitude was 180º from the original. He also said that the most terrifying thing that happened was the expectation that he & his crew would be shot by the Soviet army on the “shuttle” missions that they flew to distant targets… which meant that they’d land in soviet territory and avail themselves of the “av-gas” that had been delivered via Murmansk. The Soviets really resented that they had to give up this particular resource to these ignorant young flyers (my dad was 24 at the time)… and, twice made them wait longer than he felt necessary.
He’s still alive… and went up in a B-17 for the first time since the end of the war this last May 2nd- the day before his birthday- and said that it was louder than he’d remembered… ^..^
May 24, 2009 at 5:56 pm
Daniel
Your story and the comments in response to this post made me realize how lucky my grandfather was. Like your father, my grandfather joined the Merchant Marines to get out of being drafted into the army. As far as I know he pretty thoroughly avoided the fighting during WWII that way.
May 24, 2009 at 8:01 pm
Matt McKeon
When I was little I opened a drawer in my dad’s desk and found a big yellow patch with a black horse’s head. Dad told me he had been in the First Cavalry Division in the Korean War. I wrote nasty letters to the enemy, he told me.
Years later my brother and I pestered him about his wartime service. He was drafted and did training in Mississippi. I have a picture of him in fatigues and a helmet liner, clutching a carbine. “Killer of men” is written in pencil on the back. Truman had desegregated the army so black and white men served together, but southern society was firmly Jim Crow, and he and some northern buddies got into a fight with a bus driver who tried to make the black soldiers go the back of the bus.
They learned to operate decoding machines, then were shipped to Pusan, South Korea in June of 1951. They travelled north to the First Cav area and lived for six months in pup tents, working in the back of a truck decoding messages. In Dec. the divsion was transferred to Japan. His company had been sniped at, and harassed, but the nearest to actual danger was when another soldier dropped his carbine and sprayed their tent with bullets. He only shot at the enemy once, and missed, which was just as well, as it turned out he had been firing on South Korean construction workers.
Dad disliked the army and found military life boring and sometimes absurd. But he was proud of being in the First Cav, and he loved Japan, making friends with a Japanese family and travelling from Sapporo to Tokyo. I have dozens of photos he took of both Korea and Japan.
His family was desperately poor, so poor his father had been arrest for stealing bread in the Depression. Uncle Sam sent him to the far east, then to college on the GI Bill, giving him a chance at the middle class. It had been dirty, cold, and inconvenient, but he considered it part of being a citizen and no big deal.
May 25, 2009 at 3:07 pm
JPool
Great stories, all around.
I’m reading this while finshing up working the opening weekend for the Minnesota History Center’s new Minnesota’s Greatest Generation exhibit. The title and some of the promotional materials borrows from the tone of the Brokaw hagiography, but the exhibity itself is a really fascinating combination of Generational Cohrt study and Life History, following a group of contributors through the course of their lives. Check out the website and particularly the “Share your Story” feature.
May 25, 2009 at 5:14 pm
TF Smith
Kathy –
My father was in Italy in 1943 (after Salerno, before Anzio), and his ship was badly damaged in the last significant German air attack on an Allied port in the theater. He served in the North Atlantic and Pacific as well, and could say that he had been shot at by the Germans AND the Japanese. He got shot at in Korea as well, after having been retreaded for that one…
Actually, the shortcomings of SHINGLE (the Anzio landings) lay much farther up the chain of command than JP Lucas (who commanded the VI Corps in the initial landings); as other far more astute historians than I observed a long time ago, SHINGLE was too far north of the German MLR to flank it and the landing force was too small to open a second front, so Lucas and his troops could not do much more than what they did, which was actually the prudent thing – and after having been in action during HUSKY and having seen what happened to the VI Corps at Salerno (AVALANCHE, where it also got the short end of the stick), Lucas was right to be cautious.
The landing force amounted to two reinforced divisions, the British 1st and the US 3rd; by Jan. 29, the Allies had roughly 69,000 troops ashore; the Germans had 71,000 troops in the defense on the same date. 1-to-1 odds is pretty much a guaranteed win for the defenders on any battlefield…3-1 is the standard ratio for a sucessful assault, and Lucas didn’t have that by a long shot…
A very good recent history is Carlo D’Este’s “Fatal Decision: Anzio and the Battle for Rome” … the appropriate volumes in the Green Books “Salerno to Cassino” (Blumenson) and “Cassino to the Alps” (Fisher) are both well done as well.
Matt – Actually, man-for-man, the US Merchant Marine had a higher casualty rate during WW II than any other branch of the armed forces but the Marine Corps; your grandfather would have been statistically safer in the Army or Navy…
Golden Gate in ’48…
May 25, 2009 at 7:27 pm
wayne fontes
My uncle was wounded at Anzio. For the rest of his life he was active in the VA. I don’t think he ever recovered from his experience in the war.
To Daniel
My father volunteered for the the merchant marine because he was to young for the armed forces. While they were well payed, on the allied side I think, the merchant marine had the highest casualty rate of any of the armed services. He passed a couple of years ago. My father was not given to war stories but the little he said has always stuck with me. He told me about how the men he served with in the merchant marine were retarded in their personal growth because of the long stretches of time they spent at sea wrapped up in the routine of the ship. He was a radio operator and after the war passed up a lucerative offer to run a radio station on a tropical island. He wanted to get home and get on with his life.
When he got home their was no GI bill or any other benefits accorded to regular service men. He ended up being drafted into the infantry for Korea (no points for service in the merchant marine). He rose form private to lieutenant during his time in Korea. In the end he turned down a offer to be a captain in the regular army to return home to Cleveland and marry my mother.
His experiences were typical of his circle of friends. I think it’s safe to say that it was a different time and a different war than today
May 26, 2009 at 4:52 am
ajay
my grandfather joined the Merchant Marines to get out of being drafted into the army. As far as I know he pretty thoroughly avoided the fighting during WWII that way.
Then he was extremely lucky. The great-grandfather of a friend of mine survived the Western Front by the skin of his teeth; his son, my friend’s grandfather, thought along the same lines as your grandfather, and joined the Merchant Navy, which in the event took similar casualties to the Commandos.
On this day sixty-five years ago, American forces broke out of the Anzio beachhead and began the long process of pushing the Germans out of Italy.
“American” should of course read “Allied”. And the “long process of pushing the Germans out of Italy” had begun several months before, with the landings in southern Italy the previous September.
June 1, 2009 at 8:43 pm
George K Milam
Your reflections of your Dad was similar to mine. He was a CBM(AA) on the USS LCI(L) 220 at Tunisia, St. Maxime, Cape D’Anzio, and Salerno. He never talked about the war and he had no desire for me to serve in Vietnam. He died in the early 80’s from smoking and asbestos, no doubt from the fire retardant on the ships. He sent home $40/month to his Dad in South Carolina for 40 acres where he built a simple house. His Navy career provided a Navy annuity for life for Mom and an education for his 2 sons. He joined the Navy because he said he could not make a living selling cabbage a 3 cents a head. Your Dad and mine made it back to give us our possibilities. The others sadly were never able to do so.