On November 30th, 1899, at Sixteenth and Folsom Streets in San Francisco, Berkeley defeated Stanford 30-0 in the Big Game. The most famous trophy of the game was the Axe, which had been introduced in the baseball Big Game that spring. But with this victory, the second in a row for Cal football, Mayor James Phelan of San Francisco also awarded Berkeley a finer and more substantial trophy, a lifesize bronze statue called “The Football Players”, which stands today in a grove toward the west side of campus, on the way up into the university from downtown Berkeley.
Douglas Tilden was born in 1860, and attended the California School for the Deaf in Berkeley. He went to New York and then to Paris for further studies. He finished “The Football Players” at the end of seven years in Paris — note that, apart from being French, the players are dressed for rugby rather than American football. He did several other public sculptures in the Bay Area, including the “Baseball Player” in Golden Gate Park, the Mechanics’ Monument on Market Street downtown, and the California Volunteers’ Memorial at Market and Dolores. The monuments are bombastic in the style of the day, and hard to look at seriously now. (My daughter likes the Volunteers’ Memorial, not because she’s passionate about the Philippines War but because the horse has wings.) But the “Football Players” does something quite different than any of these, turning the conservative academic style to recognizably human ends — the composition, angles of the limbs, etc, harmonize with the gazes and the points of contact between the bodies, making a vivid if prettified image of male friendship and physical intimacy.
Photo by Flickr user marymactavish used under a Creative Commons license.
9 comments
November 30, 2008 at 3:38 pm
beamish
A cheer for psychopaths:
Give ’em the axe, the axe, the axe!
Give ’em the axe, the axe, the axe!
Give ’em the axe, give ’em the axe,
Give ’em the axe, where?
Right in the neck, the neck, the neck!
Right in the neck, the neck, the neck!
Right in the neck, right in the neck,
Right in the neck! There!
November 30, 2008 at 6:40 pm
Chris
Vance,
I’m a teacher at a school for the deaf and a deaf historian. There has been much speculation in the arts community that Tilden was gay and that was illustrated in his sculptures — much like the one in this post. There’s no documented proof of this yet, just speculation.
November 30, 2008 at 8:42 pm
Vance
Chris, that may well be (the first link I gave for Tilden there was to a site called “Gay Bears”). But I’m not sure one can draw conclusions from the sculpture alone — the sentiment and sensibility are really not out of line for the period, only better realized. It’s to a later and in some sense more prudish age that they look clearly “gay”.
beamish, you are very sensitive.
November 30, 2008 at 8:48 pm
Chris
Deaf people are known for being blunt and open-minded, so that’s probably what Tilden was thinking :-)
November 30, 2008 at 9:49 pm
Jay C
Great post, Vance: nice segue from the TDIH football game to the reminder about Douglas Tilden: just another of the talented-but-now-forgotten multitude of artists who made the Nineteenth and early Twentieth Centuries one of the more-decorated eras in history.
BTW: here’s a somewhat different photo of the Mechanic’s Monument .
And from the same link above, a rather interesting (well to me, anyway) coda, if true, to Douglas Tilden’s career:
Tilden continued to thrive as a teacher and artist for some years, but met with misfortune as his marriage dissolved, his commissions dried up and he was forced to give up his studio of 20 years. Nonetheless Tilden persevered and was rejuvenated by a stint in Hollywood in the 20s designing sculpted dinosaurs for educational films
December 1, 2008 at 5:44 am
Adam Roberts
I hadn’t seen that statue before, and it is very cool: as you say (or as you don’t quite say), splendidly, heroically gay. I vote we rename it ‘Man Removes Other Man’s Trousers.
December 1, 2008 at 8:27 am
Vance
Thanks. From other angles it’s clearer that what’s being manipulated is a bandage. Which is heroic, athletic, etc., but gives a pretext for one of the fine specimens to get his fingers on the other’s swelling curves.
According to this Flickr caption, it was “voted ‘Best Unintentionally Homoerotic Statue in the East Bay'”. “Unintentional” is surely wrong — I don’t think people missed these things, but I also don’t think that they filed them in an exclusively “homo” bin.
December 1, 2008 at 6:40 pm
josh carrollhach
It’s pretty, that’s certain. It would be gay if it wasn’t in SF, but because it IS in SF… it’s totally gay.
Not that there’s anything wrong with that.
December 1, 2008 at 10:00 pm
Martha Bridegam
Folsom Street in San Francisco has been Folsom Street in San Francisco for longer than most people remember.