On this day in history, Second Lieutenant Daniel K. Inouye, a Japanese-American from Hawaii, led his platoon into action near San Terenzo, Italy.
Inouye, a member of the 442nd Regimental Combat Team, had left his medical studies to enlist in 1943, rising to the rank of Sergeant and then getting a battlefield commission to Second Lieutenant. The war in Europe would end within the month, but the Germans were still defending their remnant of Italy fiercely. That day…but let Inouye describe the action:
We jumped off at first light. E Company’s objective was Colle Musatello, a high and heavily defended ridge. All three rifle platoons were to be deployed, two moving up in a frontal attack, with my platoon skirting the left flank and coming in from the side. Whichever platoon reached the heights first was to secure them against counterattack.
Off to the right I could hear the crackle of rifle fire as the 1st and 2nd platoons closed in on the German perimeter. For us, though, it went like a training exercise. Everything worked. What little opposition we met, we outflanked or pinned down until someone could get close enough to finish them off with a grenade. We wiped out a patrol and a mortar observation post without really slowing down. As a result we reached the main line of resistance long before the frontal assault force. We were right under the German guns, 40 yards from their bunkers. We had a choice of either continuing to move up or of getting out altogether.
We moved, and almost at once three machine guns opened up on us, pinning us down. I pulled a grenade from my belt and got up. Somebody punched me in the side, although there wasn’t a soul near me, and I half fell backward. Then I counted off three seconds as I ran toward the nearest machine gun. I threw the grenade and it cleared the log bunker, exploding in a shower of dirt. When the gun crew staggered erect, I cut them down. My men were coming up now, and I waved them toward the other two emplacements.
“My God, Dan,” someone yelled in my ear, “you’re bleeding! Get down and I’ll get an aid man.” I looked down to where my right hand was clutching my stomach. Blood oozed between my fingers. I thought, “That was no punch, you dummy. You took a slug in the gut.”
I wanted to keep moving. We were pinned down again and, unless we did something quickly they’d pick us off one at a time. I lurched up the hill again, and lobbed two grenades into the second emplacement before the gunners saw me. Then I fell to my knees. Somehow they wouldn’t lock and I couldn’t stand. I had to pull myself forward with one hand.
A man yelled, “Come on, you guys, go for broke!” And hunched over they charged into the fire of the third machine gun. I was fiercely proud of them. But they didn’t have a chance against the deadly stutter of that last gun. They had to drop back and seek protection. But all that time I had been shuffling up on the flank, and at last I was close enough to pull the pin on my last grenade. As I drew my arm back, a German stood up waist-high in the bunker. He was aiming a rifle grenade at me from a range of ten yards. And then as I cocked my arm to throw, he fired, and the grenade smashed into my right elbow. It exploded and all but tore my arm off. I looked at my hand stunned. It dangled there by a few bloody shreds of tissue, my grenade still clenched in a fist that suddenly didn’t belong to me anymore.
Some of my men were rushing up to help me. “Get back!” I screamed. Then I tried to pry the grenade out of that dead fist with my other hand. At last I had it free. The German was reloading his rifle, but my grenade blew up in his face. I stumbled to my feet, closing on the bunker, firing my tommy gun lefthanded, the useless right arm slapping red and wet against my side.
It was almost over. But one last German, before his death, squeezed off a final burst, and a bullet caught me in the right leg and threw me to the ground. I rolled over and over down the hill.
Some men came after me, but I yelled, “Get back up that hill! Nobody called off the war!”
After a while a medic got to me and gave me a shot of morphine. The German position was secured, and then they carried me away. It was April 21. [1]
Inouye’s arm was amputated at the field hospital, though the Germans had done most of the work. During his time recovering, Inouye remembered, he learned to light a cigarette one-handed and met another badly wounded American soldier, Robert Dole. For his heroism on the hill, Inouye was awarded the Distinguished Service Cross, the second highest award for valor in the American Army. Inouye remained in the Army until 1947, retiring at the rank of Captain. The loss of his arm ended any hope of a surgical career and instead he went into politics, becoming Hawaii’s first member of the House of Representatives in 1959. He swore the oath of office in the well of House holding up his left hand.
Inouye went on to be elected to the Senate from Hawaii, an office he still holds. And there things might have remained, the biography of an eminent man, torn by war but still successful. Inouye, however, exists in another historical context, that of the difficult world of American race relations. Japanese-Americans during World War II were not treated well by the U.S.. Tens of thousands were interned in the interior of the American west under Roosevelt’s Executive Order 9066. Japanese-American soldiers in a segregated Army were kept mostly in their own units and were sent to the European theater because of the assumed dangers of having them fight their supposed brethren in the Pacific. And heroic Japanese-American soldiers–like soldiers of most racial minorities–were almost entirely excluded from being awarded the Medal of Honor, the highest award for valor in the American military. Only one Medal of Honor was given to a Japanese-American soldier during the war itself. “The conscience of America,” one of those Asian-American recipients of a DSC said, “went to sleep.”
Unlike the events on that Italian hillside, however, the evaluation of those events could be rewritten, even decades later. In 1996, Congress passed a law directing:
The Secretary of the Army shall review the records relating to each award of the Distinguished-Service Cross, and the Secretary of the Navy shall review the records relating to each award of the Navy Cross, that was awarded to an Asian-American or a Native American Pacific Islander with respect to service as a member of the Armed Forces during World War II. The purpose of the review shall be to determine whether any such award should be upgraded to the Medal of Honor.
In 1998, the report came back, recommending that 22 Asian-Americans have their DSCs upgraded to Medals of Honor, Inouye among them. The award ceremonies took place in June 2000. President Bill Clinton, spoke to the assembled audience and said that the Asian-American soldiers had “risked their lives, above and beyond the call of duty. And in so doing, they did more than defend America; in the face of painful prejudice, they helped to define America at its best.” The American conscience, at least in this case and in this particular way, had woken up. In the audience was General Erik Shinseki, Chair of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, who had been born of Japanese-American parents in Hawaii in late 1942, about six months before Daniel Inouye left school and volunteered for the Army.


32 comments
April 21, 2009 at 11:35 am
Buster
Harpers published this amazing little snippet last month with LBJ on Inouye as VP material, pointing to an even higher position he might have hiked to:
I never heard as many compliments on anybody as I did on Inouye. He answers Vietnam with that empty sleeve. He answers your problems with Nixon with that empty sleeve. He has that brown face. He answers everything in civil rights, and he draws a contrast without ever even opening his mouth. I’ve never known him to make a mistake. He’s got cold, clear courage. He’s as loyal as a dog, as you must have observed. He’d never undercut you. He ought to appeal to the West. He ought to appeal to the world. It would be fresh and different. He’s young and new. And I think your secretary could call him and say, Would you please go to Utah, South Carolina, San Francisco? And I believe he could go to all of them and never lay an egg. Lady Bird said, watching him on television, This is the best man I know of except Hubert. He’s asked nothing, he’s done nothing, but he wouldn’t be miserable in the place. Now another fellow will be, and be lazy and other things. The Southern boys—I wouldn’t irritate ’em more than I had to—they all love Inouye. I don’t know why. I think one thing is that they just look at him and they can’t fuss at him and say he doesn’t love peace. In other words, the South can’t get mad at him because he’s colored, and he would appeal to every other minority because he is one.
http://harpers.org/archive/2009/03/0082396
April 21, 2009 at 11:50 am
kevin
Great post, great first comment.
You two should take the rest of the day off and go get a drink. Ari’s buying.
April 21, 2009 at 1:03 pm
Matt McKeon
“Go for Broke” that Inouye heard shouted was the slogan of the 442nd RCT.
I vaguely remember a lawyer for Nixon referring to Inouye as “a little Jap.” When called on it, the lawyer said, “well, he can call me a little American.”
April 21, 2009 at 1:20 pm
kid bitzer
the way inouye described those events?
it was totally lame and stupid. it didn’t engage my attention at all. i couldn’t understand his pov.
he’s just a crummy writer, and the reason is clear:
he didn’t *sexualize* the situation enough.
without adding the porny embellishments, where’s the drama? where’s the heroism?
April 21, 2009 at 1:33 pm
max
In 1998, the report came back, recommending that 22 Asian-Americans have their DSCs upgraded to Medals of Honor, Inouye among them. The award ceremonies took place in June 2000.
I was reading the excerpt, having never read it or heard it before so I was coming to it fresh, and I got to the point where his arm got blown off and I was thinking, ‘Man, this is MOH territory here.’ Then I got to the end of the excerpt, before you brought in the issues and it’s a DSC and I’m thinking, ‘Well. That kind of sucks. It’s a DSC and all, but ‘cmon… WTF do you have to DO? Did he not have enough stumps or something?’
Well, whaddya know.
max
['Yer combat badge don't count. Ya need more of these battle participation stars.']
April 21, 2009 at 2:05 pm
silbey
Buster, that’s an excellent anecdote. I love LBJ.
and go get a drink. Ari’s buying
Nice!
so I was coming to it fresh, and I got to the point where his arm got blown off and I was thinking, ‘Man, this is MOH territory here.’
Me, too. When he reaches across to his dangling arm and pulls the hand grenade out with his left hand, throws it at the Germans, and then shoots more Germans with his Thompson in his left hand? That’s just beyond comprehension.
April 21, 2009 at 2:08 pm
Jason B.
kb is exactly right.
And I’d always heard Inouye was a war hero and such, but somehow had never heard why. That’s an amazing story. Thanks for this post.
April 21, 2009 at 2:26 pm
silbey
By the way, if folks want to look at what the Cole Musatello ridge looks like, the Google Terrain Map of it .
April 21, 2009 at 3:09 pm
TF Smith
Sen. Inouye’s action is an example of a historical reality that would be discounted if portrayed in a work of fiction…
Minor sidenote, but by 1945, the 2nd Battalion, 442nd Infantry (and the entire RCT, for that matter) was an element of the 92nd Infantry Division, which has its own significant place in the story of the US Army in WW II.
Silbery, your google map link is a great example of why invading Italy from the south is not a good idea…
April 21, 2009 at 4:13 pm
silbey
your google map link is a great example of why invading Italy from the south is not a good idea
Indeed.
April 21, 2009 at 4:24 pm
sdh
Needs more giant squid.
Otherwise, amazing post.
April 21, 2009 at 5:58 pm
Walt
I had the same reaction as max. What more does he have to do? Beat the Germans to death with his dead hand?
April 21, 2009 at 6:31 pm
Linkmeister
The elder Senator Dan (we have two: Dan Akaka being the junior Senator) is a fixture out here. I admit that I get a little tired of the 442nd, which has been damn near fetishized in Hawai’i, but I’ve never done anything but admire Inouye.
He’s always being accused of being a porkmonger, mostly for DOD projects. The yapping we really resent has to do with brown tree snake mitigation; it sound silly, but if the critics knew what that creature has done to native bird populations on Guam they might change their tune. Inouye takes the heat for that appropriation every year without a grumble.
April 21, 2009 at 8:06 pm
Josh
WTF do you have to DO?
Die?
(Actually, looking at Wikipedia I see that only 618 out of 3446 people to receive the Medal of Honor did so posthumously. For some reason I’d thought the percentage was much higher.)
April 21, 2009 at 8:10 pm
jazzbumpa
A salute to KB for his high irony.
Inouye’s writing is elegant. His straight-forward, dispassionate account of these gripping events is all the more intensely powerful for being delivered in simple prose, with no emotionally-charged language.
Huge WOW.
April 21, 2009 at 8:11 pm
ekogan
Wikipedia says:
The 442nd famously rescued the “Lost Battalion” at Biffontaine. Pursuant to army tradition of never leaving soldiers behind, over a five-day period, from October 26 to October 30, 1944, the 442nd suffered the loss of nearly half of its roster—over 800 casualties, including 121 dead — while rescuing 211 members of the 36th Infantry Division’s 1st Battalion, 141st Infantry, which had been surrounded by German forces in the Vosges mountains since October 24.
Although that 800 casualties is listed as 400 in another article.
Only one Medal of Honor was given to a Japanese-American soldier during the war itself.
I didn’t know that a Medal of Honor was actually issued to a Nisei during WWII. What did he do that he couldn’t be reduced to a lesser award? It must be something completely superhuman, considering that Inouye’s feat only rated a DSC.
April 21, 2009 at 8:53 pm
max
(Actually, looking at Wikipedia I see that only 618 out of 3446 people to receive the Medal of Honor did so posthumously. For some reason I’d thought the percentage was much higher.)
Same article says that 60% of the WWII and later awardees received it postumously.
When he reaches across to his dangling arm and pulls the hand grenade out with his left hand, throws it at the Germans, and then shoots more Germans with his Thompson in his left hand? That’s just beyond comprehension.
After losing all that blood, he’s still conscious!
Silbery, your google map link is a great example of why invading Italy from the south is not a good idea…
If they’d just gone ahead and taken Sardinia/Corsica during Torch, they could’ve picked any place along a very long coastline to invade. Or made several different landings.
max
['Big missed opportunity.']
April 21, 2009 at 10:31 pm
Walt
ekogan: He killed Hitler.
April 21, 2009 at 10:41 pm
andrew
This is truly an amazing story. I don’t think I realized that the Medal of Honor recipients had originally been given DSCs.
Searching for the one Japanese-American soldier given the Medal of Honor earlier, I came across this item in Time, 29 March 1948, entitled “Home Country”:
April 21, 2009 at 10:42 pm
andrew
That last paragraph is supposed to be non-blockquoted, not double blockquoted. Sorry about that.
April 21, 2009 at 11:03 pm
Michael Turner
I vaguely remember a lawyer for Nixon referring to Inouye as “a little Jap.” When called on it, the lawyer said, “well, he can call me a little American.”
Hilarious.
That was John J. Wilson, who defended both Haldeman and Ehrlichman; there was plausible speculation that he’d advised Nixon on Watergate as well. As you can see from the Time article where I found one version of the story, Wilson was certainly an unapologetic racist.
The supposed provocation: Inouye had reportedly muttered “What a liar” within range of a hot microphone, after some testimony from Erhlichman concerning what he’d told a judge about the break-in at Ellsberg’s psychiatrist’s office. Inouye later said he didn’t remember saying that. (A summary of the events suggests Inouye denied saying it right after something like that was heard, but the summary is too sketchy to be sure.) Later still . . . well, I don’t know how to credit the following claim:
John J. Wilson. That little . . . lawyer.
April 22, 2009 at 3:19 am
ajay
(Actually, looking at Wikipedia I see that only 618 out of 3446 people to receive the Medal of Honor did so posthumously. For some reason I’d thought the percentage was much higher.)
Same article says that 60% of the WWII and later awardees received it postumously.
Worth remembering that the Medal of Honor was the first gallantry award created, so it may have been awarded in early days to recognise conduct which would now merit a lesser award.
Or none at all; for example, twenty were awarded for the “battle” of Wounded Knee, the largest number for any single engagement in US history.
April 22, 2009 at 5:00 am
ekogan
Sadao Munemori has his own Wiki page.
Medal of Honor Citation:
April 22, 2009 at 6:02 am
silbey
(Actually, looking at Wikipedia I see that only 618 out of 3446 people to receive the Medal of Honor did so posthumously. For some reason I’d thought the percentage was much higher.)
As others have noted, the requirements for Medals of Honor have gone up significantly. The DSC was only created in WWI, so before that MOHs were given for things that would get lesser medals (or frankly, nothing at all). Same thing has happened with the Victoria Cross in Britain. There’s an interesting academic study to be written on the evolution of medals in the modern era.
As to Munemori, he seems to have been given the MOH right away, quickly enough that the ship was named after him in 1948 and it explicitly mentions the MOH.
April 22, 2009 at 8:23 am
TF Smith
Sadao Munemori is also honored by a freeway interchange in Los Angeles County (105/405); in case passers-by think he was a famous traffic engineer or something, there is an explanatory line that reads “WW II Medal of Honor”.
Max – Although a case can be made that Sardinia-Corsica (BRIMSTONE/FIREBRAND) would have been a potentially very rewarding alternatvie to Sicily (HUSKY) in July, 1943, in November, 1942, there was not enough available sealift, naval forces, or trained assault divisions to combine an assault on Sardinia with the reinforced corps-sized operation necessary against French North Africa (TORCH); as it was, there was barely enough lift to put five division equivalents ashore in North Africa at the three widely-dispersed ports (Casablanca, Oran, Algeirs) that were TORCH’s targets.
Once the Italians joined the allies in September, Sardinia-Corsica were picked up fairly quickly in 1943 (mix of Italian and French troops, with US/UK sealift and air support) and Elba in 1944 (BRASSARD, a joint Franco-American operation).
Sardinia and Corsica were excellent stepping stones toward Provence (ANVIL/DRAGOON); there were not needed for landings on the Western coast of Italy, which could be easily mounted from Sicily and Naples, as Salerno (AVALANCHE) and Anzio (SHINGLE) demonstrated; but end-runs on the peninsula had their own inherent operational challenges, as both AVALANCHE and SHINGLE also demonstrated.
The Mediterranean strategy’s impact on Allied shipping and the French strategic situation shows the tremendous benefits it had for the Allies in 1943-45; the Italian Campaign element of the overall Mediterranean strategy, however, (along with the 1943 Dodecanese operations) shows the tremendous disadvantages it yielded in the same period. Whether the end result was a wash or not for the Allied war effort is worth considering.
April 22, 2009 at 9:22 am
andrew
As to Munemori, he seems to have been given the MOH right away, quickly enough that the ship was named after him in 1948 and it explicitly mentions the MOH.
It was awarded in 1946, I believe. If you look at the link I gave above (in the double-blockquoted paragraph), it appears that when they were reviewing the MOH recommendations for WWII, all of the Japanese-Americans recommended were given DSCs instead until a Senator intervened before they got to Munemori’s, so he was awarded the MOH. However, another source I found, but didn’t link in the comment for fear of the spam filter and now can’t find again, suggested that Munemori was actually given a DSC first but that that was quickly changed after a Senator intervened.
April 22, 2009 at 9:57 am
Micah
I learned a lot about race relations in California during the 40s when someone told me this story about Inouye: It takes place very soon after that mess in Europe that took his arm. On his way back to Hawaii he was in Oakland and needed a haircut. He went down the street decked out in his uniform (and his arm missing) to a barbershop. He walked in and the white barber immediately took one look at Inouye (who at that moment was obviously someone who’d sacrificed for the war effort) and told him ‘I don’t cut [racial epithet] hair’ and kicked him out.
April 22, 2009 at 12:06 pm
kathy a.
micah, i totally believe that story about inouye being denied a haircut in oakland. a great many japanese american families in the east bay had been sent away to internment camps during the war. at the same time, there were big racial tensions following the huge influx of african-american workers from the south, to support the war industries.
and that crap lingered; still lingers. i remember an african-american VN vet from oakland telling me how, after returning from his war, potential employers would just toss his applications in the garbage can. a few years ago, i was there when a group of elderly japanese-americans were sharing their camp experiences during those years, something they shy from speaking about even so many decades later. being swept away, their families losing homes and businesses, losing contact with relatives. the dust, the heat. the food — they all talked about what foods they could never eat again, because that was the diet every day.
April 24, 2009 at 5:21 am
valuethinker
General Eric Shinseki himself lost part of his leg, serving as a lieutenant in Vietnam.
The story goes on.
Daniel Inouyue is, I think, also an honorary Texan as the result of the valiant action of his unit, rescuing Texans during a battle in Italy.
Maybe he should have been VP.
April 25, 2009 at 5:19 pm
Prof Burgos
And in a completely shame-faced way I will point out that the 442d’s rescue of the “Lost Battalion” is the back-story to the current incarnation of the “Sgt Rock” comic book series.
Not that, you know, I’m reading them or, um, anything….
http://tinyurl.com/dzn3pp
June 10, 2009 at 1:58 pm
Marcus
Somewhere in my dim and distant recollecton I have the impression that some of the 442nd who rescued the ‘Lost Battalion’ were also honorary recipients of the Victria Cross because there were some Brits trapped there too..
Am I deluding myself or is there some substance to this?
June 10, 2009 at 2:31 pm
silbey
_Go For Broke_ (p89) says that Barney Hajiro of the 442nd got the Victoria Cross in 1948 for the Lost Battalion action, but I can’t find any record of his name on the public lists of VCs. Wikipedia claims he got the Military Medal which is a lesser award than the VC.