![]() |
This is Hannah. Well, actually this was Hannah. But before getting to the sad stuff, I want to say what a great dog she was. She was. A great dog. She was so sweet it makes my heart ache to think about her. She allowed the kids to do just about anything to her that they wanted. The baby boy would point at her and say, “dug dug,” and then leap onto her flanks. She always wagged when this happened. I wouldn’t have. I’d have been quite peeved at having the little brute attack me, cackling as he tried to climb up my back to reach my velvet ears. But Hannah always loved all of us more than we had any right to expect. Or, if it wasn’t love, you could have fooled us. Because she was big on the full-body wags.
She was also, it should be said, quite dumb. She was a lab, after all, and true to her breed never quite knew where her body ended and the rest of the world began. And she was a mess. From the moment we got her in 2002, from a guide dog training program that needed to find a home for a “defective animal,” she had all manner of health problems: allergies, ear infections, and the seizure disorder that killed her.
My wife called me at work ten days ago to let me know that Hannah was shaking uncontrollably and had been for several minutes. But I didn’t hear her — my wife — properly. I thought she said that the baby was having a seizure. And so I spent the next thirty seconds talking to my wife in a super-calm voice, asking her if maybe she needed to call an ambulance, telling her that everything would be okay, and wondering to myself if the baby would have permanent brain damage. My wife, meanwhile, kept saying, “No! Hannah!” She did that at least three time, getting progressively louder. Which left me wondering why she was allowing the dog to mess with our son while the little boy flipped around on the kitchen floor like the guppy that decided to commit suicide by leaping from our fish tank earlier this year. Finally it sank in: the dog was having the massive seizure. And I was relieved.
I feel lousy admitting that. But the baby was fine. And the dog had always been sick. As it happened, I had told my older son, a week earlier, that we’d be lucky if Hannah lived a couple more years. We needed to treat every day with her like a gift, I explained. Sappy? Sure. But he got the message. I noticed that he started to pet her more frequently: sometimes as he walked by her on the way to do something else, sometimes when he made a special trip to see her as she rested on her bed.
He always loved her. Which made sense. Because we got her for him. You see, the dog against which I’ll always measure other dogs, the sainted Megan, a sled dog — a mix of husky, lab, and greyhound — had died five years ago, suddenly, tragically, when our older boy was just a year old. And we — my wife and I — hated the idea of raising him without a dog in the house. What if he grew up and didn’t love dogs? Unacceptable. So, we put the word out that we were looking for a new pup. Within a day or two, we got a call from a guide dog service. One of their trainees couldn’t complete the program because she was “having fits.” The woman on the other end of the line explained that the dog would “need a lot of care,” would “never be much good,” and that I’d have to drive to Craig, Colorado (from Denver, where we lived at the time) to get her. And then, she threatened: “If you don’t come for her, I’ll put her down in a few days.” I hopped in the car and drove the eight hours to Craig. Where I met Hannah. Who looked like nothing so much as a land seal: sleek, playful.
To be perfectly honest, I never loved her the way I loved Megan, who I’d raised from an eight-week-old pup to be the perfect dog: smart but obedient (she used to walk off the leash with me everywhere), sweet but independent (she liked people fine but also enjoyed time alone), cute but goofy (she had one ear that pricked straight up, like a husky, and one that flopped down, like a lab, and both were way too big for her head). Plus, I got Megan when I was in graduate school. She kept me sane.
But Hannah grew on me, in large measure because our older son loved her so much. And so when my wife called me at work a second time, explaining that Hannah wasn’t moving, I rushed home. She was dead. That was obvious. On the bathroom floor, where she had gone to have her final seizure, expiring as animals often do, in her own shit and piss. I’ll spare you the existential meditations on the cold moment that it becomes clear that a body, once so wriggly and waggy, has gone lifeless.
I wrapped Hannah in a blanket, so that our older boy wouldn’t see her, and drove her limp body to the vet. The receptionist asked if I preferred to have her cremated individually or in a group. For some reason, the question brought to mind mass graves and the fate of my family during the Second World War. I opted for the individual cremation. Then I drove back to the house by myself, crying. Because she had been such a good dog. Because I would never again arrive home from a quick trip to the Co-op to find a dog so joyful that it seemed I must have been gone a month. Because I would have to tell my son what had happened. This would be his first experience with the limitlessness of death. And I had no idea how to help him understand something so foreign as mortality. I started sobbing. I pulled over.
It was easier than I thought. We cried together. He asked why she had died. I gave him an absurdly clinical answer. He asked me if Hannah had gone to heaven. I asked him what he thought. He said, “Yes, she’s in heaven, where she gets to eat what she wants and go for walks and get petted.” I wiped his eyes and agreed, saying he was probably right. He asked if she had been happy when she was alive. I said yes, she had been very happy, especially when he was around. Which was true. Then we cried some more. And he said, “This is just terribly sad.” I agreed. He asked if we would ever get another dog. I asked if he wanted one. He said, “Yes, so I can stop feeling so sad and stop missing her so much.” Well. Okay then. Time to get another dog.
We — my wife and I, along with our older boy, who loves the propaganda film Eight Below — decided that we would get a husky this time. And we would name her Luna. Because it’s a nice name for a husky. But also because our older boy thinks that Luna Lovegood, a character in the Harry Potter books, is “really sweet and good person. Because she’s so loyal. And dogs are loyal.” “So,” he explained as patiently as he could, “we should name our new dog Luna.” Allowing kids to name pets is risky. When my mom and dad let me name our dog when I was six years old, I chose Fridley, a combination of the pup’s parents’ names: Bradley and Friday. Luna, though, would work. Anyway, how could I argue with the boy’s reasoning?
I began calling every husky rescue service on the West Coast, asking if they had a dog that fit our desired profile: female (my wife feels outnumbered in a house with three boys), patient with kids (the baby still can’t be trusted not to pull a tail or grab an ear when we’re not looking), and young (we can’t have another dog die on us in the near future). A day or two later, I heard back from the wonderful people at Husky Camp. They had a dog that might work for us. So I got in the car last Saturday and drove seven hours to Rancho Cucamonga, where I met Luna.
![]() |
Luna saw me, pinned her ears back, dipped her head coquettishly, and began wagging. Then she rolled over. In the parking lot of a PetSmart. In a strip mall in the distant suburbs of Los Angeles. Hoping I would rub her belly. I did. There’s really nothing so wonderful as love at first site. Well, that’s not entirely true; there’s also having a dog lie with her head in your lap while you make the seven-hour drive, down the Grapevine, across the Central Valley on I-5, all the way home to Davis from Southern California. And then there’s the look on the older boy’s face when he sees his new dog. And the look on the new dog’s face when she sees the older boy. And the look of glee on the baby’s face, as he points at Luna and says, “dug, dug.”
Luna’s had a hard time during her ten months on this earth: she lived on the streets as recently as a month ago, ended up in a shelter for about a week, had puppies and lost all of them because she couldn’t produce milk, contracted endometriosis, had to be treated for parasites, got spayed, and then tangled with some of the other dogs at the rescue. But she’s doing okay now. She comes with me to work. She learned to open my office door, even when it’s locked, today. I found this out when a colleague poked his head into a department meeting, and said, “Um, Ari, there’s a puppy running around downstairs in the hall. I’m guessing she’s yours.” (Maybe there’s something to be said for dumb dogs like Hannah. Because smart ones like Luna make all kinds of trouble.) I think she’s beginning to realize that our house is her home. And she loves the kids, though her wagging is more restrained than Hannah’s was. The older boy told me tonight that he still misses Hannah and “won’t ever forget her.” But, he added, “now I love Luna. And she really loves me, daddy.” I agreed.
* The request came from SEK, who, here, asked me to be more human. Satisfied?



35 comments
Comments feed for this article
February 22, 2008 at 1:27 am
Hemlock
Seizures are episodes of disturbed brain function that cause changes in attention or behavior. They are caused by abnormal excited electrical signals in the brain. Death or permanent brain damage from seizures is rare, but can occur if the seizure is prolonged. Death or brain damage are most often caused by prolonged lack of breathing and resultant death of brain tissue from lack of oxygen.
In other words, your dog didn’t die from the seizure. Hannah died because she lacked oxygen. Just wanted to draw that distinction cuz death from a seizure is really, really, rare. In most cases, a trip to the vet or neurologist can determine the probability of the patient’s seizures facilitating an internal or (as in the majority of cases) accidental external blockage of the respiratory system.
Again: seizures rarely (directly) cause death.
I remember when my black lab, Casey, died. One of the top five worst day of my entire life. I remember Casey licking my face (upon my return home) after my crush rejected me at a jr. high school dance. Memories like that will stay with your son forever.
February 22, 2008 at 1:37 am
Hemlock
Correction: your dog may have died from a seizure, but the probability is pretty low. However, if she’s been having grand mal or pelican seizures every other hour and/or she can’t go outside (in extreme cases like this, even sunlight triggers seizures)…then I think it’s fair to say that she died from a seizure. Otherwise, the death may have been accidental.
BTW: Seizures don’t usually cause strokes…it’s the other way around!
February 22, 2008 at 2:35 am
Hemlock
Also, Hannah may have been in the throes of status epilepticus, a seizure that lasts more than thirty minutes. Usually happens to dogs with a history of grand mals (again, daily occurence). After thirty minutes, oxygen deprivation is more than likely a cause of death.
February 22, 2008 at 2:53 am
Benjamin Rooney
I’m not sure, Hemlock, that a copy-paste of the MedlinePlus Medical Encyclopedia entry on epilepsy is really an appropriate response to Ari’s sharing his and his family’s loss of Hannah with us.
Thank you for sharing, Ari. I am studying in Germany these last two years, and while I was away our Maggie — the beautiful golden retriever I grew up with — passed on. It’s a hard thing to lose a good dog, and I wish your family and Luna all possible happiness together.
February 22, 2008 at 4:13 am
CharleyCarp
You never forget a good dog.
February 22, 2008 at 5:11 am
Platypus
That was beautifully written.
I was the lone cat person in a family of dog lovers, it was a rough life for me and the cats. With that said, I miss the dogs from my childhood and reading your post reminded me of my childhood. Thanks :)
February 22, 2008 at 5:18 am
Ben Alpers
So sorry for your loss, Ari. I’m missing my dog, Esau, terribly while I’m in Germany. He’s nine years old and has a nasty case of arthritis in his spine, which makes him walk terribly stiffly. But he’s a great old dog. Saying good-bye to him when I left for Germany was tough, because at his age and with his back, I wasn’t sure if I’d ever see him again. But he’s apparently doing well (he’s boarding for the year out in the country with his former herding trainer), so I’m feeling cautiously optimistic.
And congrats on your new addition! Two friends of mine from grad school who teach at the University of Kansas–Jon Earle and Leslie Tuttle–have an absolutely fabulous former L.A. street dog that they adopted several years ago. It seems to be the thing to do among rising stars in the profession!
February 22, 2008 at 6:48 am
Liz
Thank you for sharing that. We’ve been through the loss of a beloved dog with our kids as well and found this book helpful:
http://www.amazon.com/Ill-Always-Love-Hans-Wilhelm/dp/0517572656/ref=pd_bbs_5?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1203691495&sr=8-5
My kids agree with your son, Luna is a wonderful name for a husky. Of course they still haven’t forgiven me for naming our new puppy “Duckie” :)
February 22, 2008 at 6:51 am
ari
It’s okay, Benjamin, everyone gets to react to something like this in their own way. Stories like the above may touch unexpected chords. Which is the point of sharing them. Anyway, thanks to you all.
February 22, 2008 at 7:48 am
LizardBreath
I’m so glad your kids are happy with Luna. Our dog is ten, and she’s lost a little of her puppy bounciness (not that you’d notice unless you knew her as a puppy. She’s still somewhere on the borderline between frolicksome and insane), and I hate thinking that some time between now and when they go away to college, the kids are probably going to have to deal with her death.
February 22, 2008 at 8:54 am
Michael
My sincere thanks, Ari. I’m struggling with how to write this in a way that won’t be dismissed as too new-agey and loosey-goosey. Also, I may be about to embarrass myself in the blogosphere by writing something that is probably blazingly obvious to everybody else.
Hannah enriched your life and the lives of your family and those around her. Strictly speaking. Had she not been there on any given day, there would have been that much less to your lives. Less meaning, less significance, less emotion, less connection. When you add all those days, those moments, together…
And then Hannah inadvertently enriched mine, because she had enriched yours so much that you were compelled to share your sense of that significance with us. My day would have been a little dryer if I hadn’t stopped by this morning, but now Hannah, whom I never knew, has got me thinking and feeling all sorts of things about her, and then my girlfriend’s dog, deaths in my family…
Amazing, isn’t it? I know the smarter and/or more curmudgeonly out there will say, “Get over yourself, a sick and ‘quite dumb’ dog died, and you’re making too big a deal of it.” And they’re undoubtedly right. But I’m putting myself at risk of looking like an overly sentimental nut job because I think it would be terrible if we made too little a deal of it.
In summation, then, I plan to raise my glass to Hannah tonight, and then to my girlfriend’s dog, too. And I think it would be great way to increase Hannah’s renown if others (virtually) joined me.
February 22, 2008 at 9:40 am
rootlesscosmo
My sympathy, Ari. I think (I get to issue these profundities because I’m a certified Alte Fartzer) that living with animals is good for us, because it gives us multiple oppportunities of being gratuitously kind. You scratch Luna’s belly because it makes Luna happy; it makes you happy too, but, I believe, that’s because it makes her happy. That’s as virtuous a circle as any I know of, and drawing your kids into it is a really good thing to do. Good wishes to you all, and sympathy again on losing Hannah.
February 22, 2008 at 9:54 am
RobinMarie
Thank you for writing this Ari, really. It’s always so heartwarming to hear from other dog lovers about their pets and their experience with them. My boyfriend has a black lab named Daisy he got this summer, who is quite possibly the sweetest dog on earth, putting up with Maverick gently nibbling on her leg when he wants her to play with him, and stealing all her toys right out of her mouth so she will chase him. When we hang out it is almost like a family, with the dogs taking over the couch and sniffing our dinner plates. While Daisy and I snuggle on the couch I realize that my dream of having dogs as a huge part of my life has come true; in undergrad I could never get one and was always sad when I saw them around town.
And I think you’re absolutely right about dogs and Graduate school; a huge chunk of my time that isn’t spent working is spent on Maverick, taking him on walks, going to the vet, or chasing him around the house when we play keep-away. There is nothing like having a little puppy to take care of and look after. It makes every day seem purposeful and your problems trivial. And every time I get home no matter what happened out there, in here I am plastered with kisses from Maverick and am the center of his little puppy existence. And I don’t really know what I would do without him.
So anyway, it’s really nice to hear a story from another dog lover. Because it really is a special experience and it’s hard to describe sometimes for people who haven’t had it, but I think you’ve done a great job here. I’ll try to come by and see Luna today, and if she’s not there I will come by again until I meet her :).
February 22, 2008 at 10:20 am
SEK
Satisfied?
Yes, Ari. I needed a good cry.
February 22, 2008 at 10:23 am
Vance Maverick
Thanks, Ari, this is really good. I appreciate the honesty tangled up in the sentiment.
Maverick gently nibbling on her leg
We’re not all like this, really.
February 22, 2008 at 10:38 am
Lisa Justice
Ari, I’m weeping in my office as I read this. I’m heartbroken. I loved Hannah too, and I’m so sorry to hear about her death. But it sounds like Luna won the jackpot! Congratulations on the new canine addition to your family.
February 22, 2008 at 11:15 am
Hemlock
I owned and loved Casey for 12 years. I raised her, lived with her, took walks with her, took her to the vet, and loved her in an infinite amount of ways. Her death changed my life. There is no way in hell I can’t sympathize with the Kelmans and especially their son.
“I’m not sure, Hemlock, that a copy-paste of the MedlinePlus Medical Encyclopedia entry on epilepsy is really an appropriate response to Ari’s sharing his and his family’s loss of Hannah with us.”
Would you have rather me pulled it from the UCD Health Center’s guide? My family’s neurologist and Casey’s vet have expressed willingness to send Mr. Rooney an email with a detailed description of seizure disorders.
February 22, 2008 at 11:21 am
Sandie
Beautiful post, Ari. So sorry to hear about Hannah, and I do remember sweet Megan. Talking to kids about death is really difficult, especially when they’re that young and that full of unrepressed emotion. I’ve got to think that talking to them about sex is a whole lot easier.
February 22, 2008 at 11:26 am
ari
Hemlock, please don’t take it too personally. Really, I think Benjamin was just reacting to the clinical nature of your comment. Which, again, was just fine with me. Everyone reacts to this sort of post in their own way. That’s the point, I think.
And Sandie, thanks, I appreciate it. Which goes for everyone who has expressed sympathy. But when it comes to talking about sex with the boys, I have no idea what I’m going to do. My parents, who are very kind and decent people, made such a hash of that one, maybe I’ll just do the exact opposite.
February 22, 2008 at 11:40 am
Hemlock
Yours was relief, mine was depression. In this case, I wanted to clarify that Hannah’s death didn’t result from a “defective” trait. The love that was all Hannah was no defect. I respect you for raising and practically creating a life. The pain will never fully go away as long as you still love her.
February 22, 2008 at 1:32 pm
Hemlock
P.S. I realized something: when writing the comment, I thought the citation was obvious (given the medical definition connotations). Evidently it wasn’t. Hence my use in the next paragraph of “in other words.” I’m not concentrating on correct citations, quotes, spellings , or use correct grammar in any of my comments…and I never will.
And as far as I can tell, nobody else is, either. I question the motivations of past commenters’ critique of Professors Kelman’s and Professor Rauchway’s specific facts/writing/etc. In any case, the point here is mourning and the loss of life–not Mr. Rooney’s psychosexual passive aggressiveness.
February 22, 2008 at 4:02 pm
KRK
Thanks for the lovely post. Happy to know that Luna has found a good home and that your family has found another dog to love.
Given that even the longest-living dogs and cats have lifespans far shorter than we do, loving them necessarily means inviting the grief of losing them. The fact that so many people do this, repeatedly, is a tribute to the high concentration of joy and love that gets crammed into those short lives.
I always feel bad for a new pet that follows a particularly beloved one. So much to live up to. So hard to find one’s own idiosyncracies un(der)appreciated. I’m glad you found much to love in Hannah even though she could never replace Megan.
As for kids and the death of a pet, I believe that having such experiences is a huge part of learning about life and loss and moving on while still remembering with love the one who’s gone. One of my earliest memories is climbing onto my father’s lap in tears as he explained to my sister and me that our cat had died. Soon thereafter, my father also died, so it turned out that one of the few memories I have of him is him telling us not to be sad for Sparky because she wouldn’t be sick anymore.
February 22, 2008 at 4:09 pm
silbey
not Mr. Rooney’s psychosexual passive aggressiveness.
When I read your first comment, I had the same reaction as Rooney: that reacting to a sad tale with a litany of diagnostic corrections was deeply unfeelingly. You explained your aim better in a later comment, which I appreciate.
February 22, 2008 at 4:10 pm
urbino
Now I miss her, too. Thanks a lot, Ari. Such a sweet face, too. (The dog’s, not yours. Well, okay, yours, too.)
February 22, 2008 at 4:46 pm
silbey
deeply unfeelingly
*unfeeling*, sorry.
February 22, 2008 at 6:20 pm
New Kid on the Hallway
I’m so sorry about Hannah - what a lovely face she had! I know what you mean about pets keeping you sane in grad school, too - I got my oldest cat just before I graduated from college and took him out to grad school with me. For a while he was the only reason I had to go home at the end of the day and the only local person who cared what was up with me. Cats live longer than dogs, but I have to face the fact that he won’t be with me much longer, and I will be a useless mess when that happens.
And Luna is beautiful! Huskies are awesome dogs.
February 22, 2008 at 10:41 pm
Hemlock
“Pyschosexual passive aggressiveness”….always falling back to reductionist Derridian binaries. Need to stop doing that. I’m still in training here, people…need to shift to an analytical intention/socioeconomic causation mode.
Urbino, Ari, per se, thanks for the constructive mentoring.
February 22, 2008 at 10:47 pm
Hemlock
By the way, I’ve been reticient on the dog issue for a few years. I respect your son for moving on so quickly (that’s not sarcasm…I think that’s a sign of emotional fortitude). I just couldn’t do the death thing again…taking her into that vet’s room with the needle and seeing her go away in a couple of minutes. I’m sorry.
But, I’ve been leaning towards another lab…perhaps I’ll name her Hannah. =)
February 23, 2008 at 9:39 am
G.D.
This was a wonderfully moving entry.
I’m at work welling up.
February 25, 2008 at 7:20 am
bitchphd
Aww, fabulous. Both lovely dogs. We raised guide dogs for 4H as kids–they both “flunked” and although my sister kept hers, mine was taken in by a kind family like yours; they sent me a photograph the next year. So sweet.
And huskies. Yay huskies! Plus, “Luna” is my cat’s name, so of course I completely approve.
February 25, 2008 at 9:43 pm
Zach Morgan
Nice entry on the girls. Hannah really was a sweet dog, I’ll miss her…I still miss Megan too. I hope Luna gets to meet Jinx some day, who unfortunately had her ear bitten through the other day by a god-damned golden retriever in the park–a breed I believe to be nearly as dangerous as labs. To quote bitchphd “Yay huskies!”
February 25, 2008 at 9:52 pm
ari
So this is what it takes to get you to comment on the blog, Zach? Fine, you can expect more maudlin dog blogging in the future.
May 4, 2008 at 8:23 am
Mike Boom
I just lost my best friend (PEANUT) 3 days ago to a Grad Maul Seizure. She had about 4 seizures before the big one. They only lasted 1 min to 2 minutes long. This one lasted 30 mins maybe 45 mins. She start having one then she would sort of calm down, then another one started up. There’s nothing I could do at 2 in the morning. I’m still very upset about it all, still crying everytime I think of her or see something of hers. I’ve had her at the vets, they did blood tests etc,,didn’t find anything wrong. But they said it’s one of those things. She died in my arms ,, I miss her soooo much. She was only a year and a half years old. Love them to death when you have them, because you never know. My life changed overnight. Take care everyone. Mike B.
May 8, 2008 at 12:00 am
Blog Dog (part 1) « The Edge of the American West
[...] above), a Border Collie pup we call Maggie. Which raises an important question: what happened to Luna? Well, that’s a long and sad story. So here [...]
May 13, 2008 at 6:47 am
Mike
My dog (Peanut) died about two weeks ago from a grand maul also. She was only 1 1/2 years old. She has had a few small seizures ,maybe they would of lasted a minute or two at the most. I had her at the vets ,they did blood work etc and everything looked okay. She would have them when she was in a deep sleep. I was always checking her out the best I could when she was sleeping but I can’t do it when I’m asleep. My wife woke me up about 1:15 in the morning saying,,she’s having one of her seizures!!. So, I bent down beside her as I always did,,and talked to her in a positive voice. Saying everything is going to be fine… But this seizure would come on,then slow down,,then pick up again. It lasted about 45 minutes. When she was sort of coming out of it, I would tell her that we would go out after,, just me and her ..She wagged her tail a couple of times,,then it started again. I miss her so much. She is,was my best friend. I’m still very upset, even writing this. So I know what it is like to lose a good dog. We also got another dog,,a female Boxer named Jewels. She will be loved just as much as Peanut was. RIP Peanut,, Love You, Dad