
It really is. The Confederate flag has been kicked around for long enough. Thank goodness we’ve finally found a presidential candidate brave enough to stand up for white Southerners. Because, y’know, “all the average guy with a Confederate Flag on his pickup truck is saying is: he’s proud to be a Southerner.” And also: Macaca! I’m guessing he’s saying that, too. Of if not saying it, perhaps thinking it.
Okay, that last part was all me. But the first part comes courtesy of Americans for the Preservation of American Culture (APAC).** Which is under siege. American culture, that is.*** Forget the global hegemony enjoyed by Hollywood, McDonalds, and the English language (not as certain, I know). If Mike Huckabee, eating fried squirrel and wearing St. Andrew’s Cross drawers, isn’t elected president of these United States, the terrorists will have won. And also that dark fella Obama.
So the crazed racists gentlemen behind APAC have manned the battlements. They’re running some mighty informative commercials in South Carolina, the Cradle of Secession, making sure that their kinfolk and friends know that John McCain hates the Confederate Flag. And America. Which is fine by me. Because anyone who wants to derail the Straight Talk Express is, in some twisted way, probably a friend of the Republic — even if they also embrace treason. Weird.
Taking a quick trip to neo-Confederate 527ville, we learn that the APACers are homespun folks. They worry that “political correctness is ruining our land.” And you know what? McCain is one PC dude. He reviles his heritage, allowing that his ancestors who fought with the Confederacy “were on the wrong side of history.”
So, what does APAC propose that we do to beat back this threat from McCain and the Dixie-hating**** minions of political correctness? Glad you asked:
Restoring your grandchildren’s birthright to its rightful place of Honor is a tall mountain to climb, but well within the capabilities of men and women descended from these patriots who stood so tall and firm. This is our watch, this is our challenge; it is our turn to stand tall and firm.
Now, is the time to stand firm and dig our line in the sand, with a backhoe!
And maybe it’s also time to learn how to use a comma. With a backhoe!
Huck’s position, issued in between mouthfuls of squirrel, is: not a federal issue.
You don’t want people from outside the state coming in and telling you what to do with your flag. If somebody came to Arkansas and told us what to do with our flag, we’d tell ‘em what to do with the pole.
Homespun! And also: outside agitators. I’m so hearing Hukabee’s dog whistle.
But what about APAC’s claim that what’s often mislabeled the Stars and Bars***** or the Confederate Battle Flag****** is just a symbol for proud Southerners. Nothing on that from Huck. McCain, though, straight-talking straight-talker that he is, isn’t pandering. And good for him. (My fingers! They burn!) Because, as evidenced by its cameos at cross burnings, Klan rallies, and, until the year 2000, atop the South Carolina statehouse*******, the Confederate flag is very much a fetish for white supremacists. To say otherwise is both absurd and disingenuous.
How this primary season became a referendum on Civil War memory is anyone’s guess. But the GOP’s need to maintain a solid South has a lot to do with it. If this keeps up, it’s possible that instead of turning to the ghost of Ronald Reagan at their brokered convention in St. Paul, the Republicans will have to try to convince the reanimated corpse of George Wallace to switch parties and bear their standard.
[Editor's Note: Special thanks to Matt W, who goaded me into putting up this post. If you don't like what I've written, I suggest you take a look at his post on the subject and then fill his in-box with hate mail. Thanks also to Greg Sargent, whose post at talkingpointsmemo brought this story to my attention. With a backhoe!]
* Let me be clear about one thing: I don’t pick these fights; they pick me.
** Like AIPAC. But with fewer Jews.
*** Seriously, it needs protecting. Be vigilant. There are Canadians in our midst.
**** Also, in fairness, straight-talking.
***** Looked too much like the Stars and Stripes (aka: the American flag). So was discarded. Because any resemblance to the American flag will not be tolerated by true patriots. Duh.
****** Was square, not rectangular, and flew throughout the Civil War. Most famously over Robert E. Lee’s Army of Northern Virginia. Which also fought to protect American culture. Wait, no, that’s wrong. Which fought to destroy the Union and preserve slavery. That’s the same thing, right? Kind of?
******* Honestly, I can’t quite figure this out. It may still fly over the South Carolina state capitol. But I think it’s just in front of the statehouse, next to a monument honoring the Confederate dead. Wherever the flag may still be, the Old Ball Coach thinks it should be gone entirely. And when Steve Spurrier is the voice of reason in your state, you’ve got big problems.


34 comments
January 17, 2008 at 9:38 pm
David Carlton
” as evidenced by its cameos . . . until the year 2000, atop the South Carolina statehouse*******, the Confederate flag is very much a fetish for white supremacists.”
The Confederate battle flag indeed no longer flies atop the SC Statehouse. The US flag does. Is that evidence that the US flag is a fetish of white supremacists?
January 17, 2008 at 9:52 pm
ari
Yes, David, that is exactly what I mean. You are a subtle reader of blog posts.
January 17, 2008 at 9:56 pm
ari
My response to your comment, I think, reads as far too glib. I was assuming you were joking and responded in kind. After re-reading your comment, I’m less certain of your intent. And if you were serious in the first instance, I would have responded very differently. Specifically, with more respect, as I’m an admirer of your work, and the blogosphere is a hothouse for misconstruals and petty quarrels. Anyway, I meant no offense.
January 17, 2008 at 10:21 pm
eric
I believe it flies on the grounds of the statehouse, but not atop the building.
January 17, 2008 at 10:24 pm
ari
That’s what I thought. Next to the Civil War memorial. But the link in the post seemed to indicate otherwise.
January 17, 2008 at 11:09 pm
paulbeard
Says a lot about the Palmetto State if Spurrier is the Voice of Reason. So what about the crescent on the state flag anyway? I thought crescents (or even croissants) were suspect . . .
January 18, 2008 at 12:43 am
bitchphd
I hate arguments about the stupid Confederate Flag. Yes, racists love it, and so do good ol’ boys and rednecks, and the shittiest thing about the entire subject is that all it takes is liberal fascist elites like us pointing out that, uh, it’s a symbol of racism to make even reasonable southerners get their backs up. Nothing like good old regional ressintement.
Also, Huckabee sucks.
January 18, 2008 at 2:51 am
mjm
While it is simple to brand everyone who displays the Confederate Battle Flag as racist, you can’t go very wrong doing so.
Why do we waste our time on these people? I
January 18, 2008 at 5:32 am
matt w
racists love it, and so do good ol’ boys and rednecks
But as far as I can tell, who does not love it is black people. And if the good ol’ boys and rednecks haven’t noticed that, it’s a problem, and if they have, it’s a different problem.
all it takes is liberal fascist elites like us pointing out that, uh, it’s a symbol of racism to make even reasonable southerners get their backs up
But, judging by the APAC website, it gets their backs up just as much when a good ol’ southerner like Fred Thompson points out that the flag is a symbol of racism (to many people).
At the very least there’s a point to be made to reasonable southerners that, hey, think about the history of this flag and what it means, and if it’s a symbol of southern pride then why don’t you ever see southern black people with Confederate flags on their cars? It could be a teachable moment about race relations, at least for reasonable southerners. The problem is that it makes it too easy for northern white people to otherize racism and the south — there’s no cause for me to be smug up here in Whiteland. But, given that the Confederate flag wound up on state capitols as part of a white supremacist reaction against civil rights, it seems like condemning it is the least we can do.
And the main point is taking more of the measure of the amiable-seeming Huckabee. He chose to defend the Confederate flag the way that the people defended white supremacy, by complaining about people coming in from out of state. That’s the same way George W. Bush defended the Confederate flag in 2000. Huckabee gets inexplicably good press even from some liberals, but he seems like he’s every bit the asshole W is.
(BTW, anyone know the origin of the phrase “outside agitators” or something similar in this context? Googling around there doesn’t seem to be a famous quote from anyone involving it, but I found this from 1918, about strikebreaking on the Third Avenue Railway — would that be the 4/5/6?)
January 18, 2008 at 5:41 am
standpipe
I think the Third Ave. Railway was an elevated jobbie.
January 18, 2008 at 5:54 am
eric
In this article from 1892 on an agricultural conference in London, you read that “Mr. Baker … declared that the farmers would not submit to the terms of outside agitators, who want to fix laborers’ wages.” It appears this is its earliest instance in the NYT, and it sounds like it was already a stock phrase for opposing unions.
January 18, 2008 at 5:55 am
Wow!! « Stuff ‘n stuff ‘n more stuff
[...] 18, 2008 That Huckabee! Posted in Uncategorized [...]
January 18, 2008 at 5:58 am
eric
It is in the Journal of the Royal Agricultural Society of England in 1874 — “though inflammatory language has been used, and hard and unjust things uttered by the outside agitators of the movement….”
January 18, 2008 at 6:01 am
eric
And in the British Farmer’s Magazine of 1872: “he objected to outside agitators who knew nothing of the matter interfering to attempt to accomplish an object which could better be done without them.”
January 18, 2008 at 6:04 am
eric
In Fifty Years Among the Baptists, in 1860, it appears with respect to the churches — “by a combination of influences, political and religious, between outside agitators, and indisde managers, many of our strong and harmonious churches … were shaken to their center on mere matters of opinion.”
January 18, 2008 at 7:17 am
John B.
hey, here is sunny Virginia it’s Lee-Jackson Day! A state Holiday for state workers to celebrate their southern confederate heroes born in ole’ Virginny…(although most know that Jackson was born in what is now West (by God) Virginia, it was at the time of his birth Virginia…)
at least the good peanut farmer legislators that we have here in our fine state have moved Lee-Jackson Day from it’s unique place along with the the Federal Holiday of Martin Luther King, Jr. Day and given it it’s own Day on the Friday before the Monday of aforementioned MLK, Jr. Day, thus gving state workers the most unique 4 day weekend in the Union (IMO).
This was the only way the same gentlemen farmer legislators would accept the Federal Holiday celebrating the civil rights leader, by uniquely placing it together with those famous dead confederate generals of yore.
Truly funny and ironic.
It was only later that they separated the two holidays giving us this fine 4 day weekend.
Truly something to shout about! Hooah!
January 18, 2008 at 8:21 am
Jan 18 2008: Last Friday of freedom! « blueollie
[...] Huckabee: sucks up to the conferdates. So the (crazed racists) gentlemen behind APAC have manned the battlements. They’re running some [...]
January 18, 2008 at 12:20 pm
bitchphd
Matt W is of course right, especially in the longest paragraph of his comment. But, I dunno, condemming cultural symbols/practices from a position that is, itself, part of what said symbols are reacting against seems at the very least counter-productive. Especially when it’s what the symbols represent–rather than the symbols themselves–that are the real problem.
It’s sort of akin to getting all wound up about flag-burning because you think that somehow prohibiting it is going to actually achieve something meaningful.
January 18, 2008 at 1:26 pm
ari
B, I totally agree. But my original post really wasn’t about the need to do away with the Confederate flag. It was about what a candidate is saying to the electorate when he (in this case) chooses to wrap himself in that flag. So sure, the post pokes at neo-Confederates. Which, as you say, almost certainly isn’t going to accomplish much. At the same time, though, it raises the question of what’s going on in this primary season, when big chunks of the GOP field are associating themselves with neo-Confederates. These people want to be president of the USA, or so they say, not the CSA. Oh, I don’t know.
January 18, 2008 at 2:32 pm
urbino
The really fun part of all this is that if Huck wins, thirty years from now a lot of Very Serious People will be insisting he was neither a racist nor appealing to racism; he rilly, rilly did believe in states’ rights. Rilly.
January 18, 2008 at 5:19 pm
bitchphd
Oh, I wasn’t really playing the “this post is stupid and useless” game. I hate it when people do that–it’s a blog, for crying out loud.
You’re right, of course, about what the fuck the GOP is (still, and forever) doing. I wouldn’t be surprised if Huckabee were actually too fucking stupid to realize the implications of that kind of nonsense–he strikes me as not being a deep thinker. Oops, there I go casting aspersions on Southern Baptists.
January 18, 2008 at 5:43 pm
Josh
So has anyone here read this book? I have it sitting on my shelf, and now I’m wondering if it’s worth bumping it up the to-read stack.
January 18, 2008 at 5:45 pm
Josh
This also seems apropos.
January 18, 2008 at 5:54 pm
ari
I haven’t read the book, though I, too, have it on my shelf. I’m not at all sure from whence it came… Odd books have a way of showing up in my office, like they’ve walked in themselves during the night, drawn by the knowledge that they’ll find kindred spirits. It’s eerie. That said, I have read this book, which is as unfair and reductive as my original post. But also funnier and, in a couple of chapters, very disturbing.
May 4, 2008 at 1:37 am
chris hines
Well im a Maina at the tip of new england n i love the flag …Hicks all around the USA should be able to be proud to wave the flag..!
May 4, 2008 at 11:04 am
john p
What’s scary is when you see a Confederate flag in California…a little more than southern pride.
July 22, 2008 at 2:46 am
Another Southron
I think that all of you “closed-minded” people out there who think the Confederate Flag is just another symbol of racism need to get an actual, authentic education… not the one that for nearly a century and a half has been handed down by our public schools (as great as they are)… which, by the way, is teaching the re-written history handed to them by those wonderful “yankee liberators” after torching and destroying all schools and presshouses in the south… (Wait, that means that our books were printed in the north right?) Rather you people like it or not, the CONFEDATE STATES of AMERICA is an Occupied NATION… That’s right, I said it. Get over it. And by the way, slavey was on it’s way out of the South before the war! Good ‘ole Lincoln (a tyrant) is our only Pres in American history to ever order a mass public execution… didn’t know that either, huh? And the North’s money came from mainly SLAVE TRADE and COTTON in the South… so wouldn’t it be kinda like today’s American Gov’t going to war over OIL? Hey, I also want to point out that I have black friends that PROUDLY display their True nations’ Flag… THE STARS & BARS! Racism my @$$!
July 22, 2008 at 4:52 am
neocynic
That was pretty good. All you’re missing is a red rubber nose. And a pair of big, floppy shoes.
July 22, 2008 at 4:53 am
ari
You’re a class act, Southron. Thanks for the comic relief.
July 22, 2008 at 5:14 am
Walt
The entire Internet is now trolling me 24-7.
July 22, 2008 at 5:25 am
ari
The entire Internet is now trolling me 24-7.
That must suck. It’s a mighty big internet. Although, come to think of it, it fits inside my MacBook Air. [confused now]
July 22, 2008 at 5:27 am
ari
Look on the bright side, Walt: the mainstreaming of calling McCain old.
July 22, 2008 at 6:36 am
Walt
That “confused now” joke was sufficiently funny that I can’t think of a single mean thing to say. Damn you, Ari! Damn you to Hell!
July 22, 2008 at 6:50 am
Cala
Historical question for the historians: has it been common to fly the Confederate flag in the South ever since the end of the Civil War? Or did it go into remission for a while, and spring back later?